Rao Trang 3 accident suggests a reconsideration of small hydropower projects

Hydropower is meant to not only generate renewable energy but also contain floods and regulate water currents.

Yet aside from the pros, it has its cons which are deforestation, population resettlement and adverse effects on the natural aquatic environment, to name but a few. Human impacts on nature concern both sides of a coin. Therefore, planners have to weigh pros and cons to pick the option that offers the best plus and the smallest minus, and minimize negative impacts on the environment.

Rao Trang 3 accident suggests a reconsideration of small hydropower projects

Environmental effects of hydropower projects began to capture public attention some time ago when small- and medium-size hydropower plants mushroomed in many provinces while ignoring the awareness of environmental protection and deforestation. In these cases, hydropower project developers failed to replant forests they had promised, destroyed more forests, caused downstream water resources to drain and demolished multiple local ecosystems.

The accident at the construction site of Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant earlier this month has left 30 killed or missing, including a military rescue team of 13 members.

Scientists have for long warned against the downside of small hydropower plants, from the point of view and policies to regulations and implementation.

Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant was licensed by the People’s Committee of Thua Thien-Hue Province in November 2008. The construction site of the project is on the Rao Trang River, a tributary of the Bo River, in Phong Xuan Commune, Phong Dien District. The project’s proprietor is Truong Son, a construction consultant. Rao Trang 3 has a designed capacity of 11MW on a planned area of 11.1 hectares, of which the area of the reservoir bed is 8.8 hectares.

In a tropical monsoon climate country which is still poor like Vietnam, storms and floods are frequent while natural calamities are devastating. Although the State has gained experiences and taken measures to cope with them, the problem remains serious.

As an American proverb goes, “The forest is the poor man’s overcoat. Thua Thien-Hue Province is no exception. The localities in the Central Highlands and the northern mountainous region, hydropower projects have resulted in deleterious consequences.

Reality in Vietnam has indicated that overexploitation of small hydropower plants means not only upsetting the geological and ecological balance but also destroying centuries-old heritages of local ethnic minorities. Hydropower planning has severed river deltas, devastated forests only to give birth to dead rivers, and destroyed riverscapes and waterfalls.

Risks of landslides have been warned

As far as the author is concerned, the delegation to provincial authorities to appraise and approve small hydropower projects can be considered a mistake. Provincial authorities do not have the needed capacity while group interest cannot be eliminated.

As hydropower plants may be lucrative, investment is attractive even to enterprises which are from other sectors not related to power generation. However, such profit must be exchanged for the ruin of social and natural environments.

With a length of less than 30 kilometers, the Rao Trang River has to shoulder four hydropower plants whose total capacities are 89MW. This overexploitation partly reveals incongruities of upstream hydropower generation planning in Thua Thien-Hue Province.

The Institute of Geosciences and Mineral Resources under the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment has once issued warnings about high risks of landslides and rockfalls in the environs of Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant. What’s more, it also involves dangers of rugged terrains.

The institute’s vice director, Dr. Trinh Xuan Hoa, said in 2019, his institute conducted a survey on landslides in Phong Dien District, including the area of Rao Trang 3 Hydopower Plant. Hoa said the survey showed that at all the sites, landslides occurred when a rain came down or followed a prolonged heavy rain. According to statistics, 40 out of 42 landslide sites were on the manmade talus, the sloping side of an earthwork that tapers to the top.

 

“High risks of landslide and rockfalls have been warned against the main site of A Lin 1-Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant,” said Hoa. “It was suggested that a detailed survey of landslide at the scale of 1:25,000 should be carried out. A map of zoning landslide/rockfall risks will be made in 2021.”

Notably, in June this year, the team undertaking the project “Examination, Evaluation and Zoning of Risks of Landslides/Rockfalls in Vietnam’s Mountainous Area” handed over the results to the Thua Thien-Hue Committee for Search and Rescue.

From the above information, more details should be worked out about (1) whether the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report of Rao Trang 3 mentioned the warnings made in 2019?; (2) If the report had been made prior to 2018, why did not Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant take any action to respond to those warnings?; and (3) A proposal was made to conduct a survey on landslides at the scale of 1:25,000, and ever since, whether this suggestion has been considered? If the answer is “no,” then why should nobody take any measures to respond to such an important proposal? If the answer is “yes,” then what has been made and what are the results?

Submission of the EIA report does not mean “end of story”

The above three questions do not mean to find fault with somebody. They are just to make clear what has really happened and draw a lesson for the future.

The fatal accident at Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant suggests that the submission of the EIA report does not means the parties involved have fulfilled their responsibilities. Sponsors of some official development aid projects require not only EIA reports as stipulated in Vietnam but also ask for a subsequent environment study which must include updated environmental information and suggest measures to manage the environment in line with the proposals in the EIA report and other proposals. The environmental references of the project in question must be updated each time new information is available and the project’s environmental management system must be revised in accordance with updates.

If Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant had conformed to the above procedures, the heart-rendering accident involving 30 deaths could have been avoided. Therefore, it is time to have stringent regulations on the post-EIA report tasks. Although risks of accidents were indicated, no measures were taken, or measure taken belatedly and unprofessionally.

Obviously, in addition to benefits already known, Vietnam’s networks of hydropower and irrigation projects may pose more risks to those projects themselves but also the surrounding areas.

That’s why the tasks of research and planning should be adequately paid attention to in order to ensure sustainable development and avoid overreliance of companies’ suggestions.

Small hydropower projects are often located in remote or mountainous regions, where rough terrains pose high risks of landslides during the rainy season. Consequently, ample safety measures must be taken to ensure safety.

Natural calamity prevention and fighting in Vietnam has been considered a struggle for existence, which is a tough job. It is therefore necessary to have well-trained rescue teams, accurate early warnings and specialized equipment ready for accidents at any time.

The lethal accident at Rao Trang 3 has clearly shown that the situation of small hydropower plant projects is currently chaotic. It is a bitter lesson we should learn.

SGT

Military forces intensifies rescue operations at Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant

Military forces intensifies rescue operations at Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant

Rescue forces made up of military personnel, medics, and members of the police have urgently joined rescue efforts to look for the missing victims of a landslide which hit Rao Trang 3 Hydropower Plant in the central province of Thua Thien Hue.

 
 

Other News

.
Made in Vietnam portable air filters helping fight COVID 19
Made in Vietnam portable air filters helping fight COVID 19
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  24/12/2020 

Vietnamese scientists have invented a new portable air filter to help facilities such as airports, hospitals, and bus stations ensure a safe working environment that protects employees and customers alike from risks associated with COVID-19.

Local technology enterprises must regain the market
Local technology enterprises must regain the market
FEATUREicon  24/12/2020 

"Vietnam's overall economic growth rate is below 10%. The growth target for digital technology enterprise should be set at 15-20% and even more," said Deputy PM Vu Duc Dam at the National Forum for Developing Technology Enterprises.

12 illegal loggers prosecuted for destroying forest in Phu Yen
12 illegal loggers prosecuted for destroying forest in Phu Yen
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  23/12/2020 

Phu Yen Police have started the prosecution of 12 illegal loggers related to deforestation in Tay Hoa and Song Hinh districts.

Hanoi hosts national forum on development of digital enterprises
Hanoi hosts national forum on development of digital enterprises
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  23/12/2020 

A national forum aimed at fostering the development of local digital enterprises kicked off on December 23 in the capital as part of a one-year review since the implementation of the “Make in Vietnam” strategy.

Hanoi’s residents alarmed at indoor air pollution
Hanoi’s residents alarmed at indoor air pollution
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  22/12/2020 

Outdoor air pollution is considered a major factor leading to increased indoor air pollution in Hanoi.

Network operators are not doing enough to prevent spam calls, texts
Network operators are not doing enough to prevent spam calls, texts
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  22/12/2020 

Millions of fake calls and tens of thousand of subscribers in the last five months were handled, but network operators do not appear to be sufficiently determined to fight against spam calls.

Vietnam's opening of internet leads to digital transformation path
Vietnam's opening of internet leads to digital transformation path
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/12/2020 

Vietnam has gained major achievements after more than 20 years of opening its doors to the internet. 

Wildlife conservation contributors to be honoured
Wildlife conservation contributors to be honoured
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/12/2020 

The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment will honour organisations and individuals that have made great contributions to wildlife conservation between 2010 and 2020.

5G equipment ownership has a national strategic meaning
5G equipment ownership has a national strategic meaning
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/12/2020 

The ownership of 5G equipment has a national strategic meaning, heard at a recent seminar on 5G in Hanoi.

Life-changing technology assists Vietnam’s healthcare transformation
Life-changing technology assists Vietnam’s healthcare transformation
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

The Vietnamese government and the Ministry of Health will hold a conference called eHealth Vietnam Summit 2020 late this month.

Small contributions, big impact
Small contributions, big impact
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

“Changing Mindset Little by Little” is what Denise Truong, a French Chinese lady, is trying to leave through her Trash Hero Ho Chi Minh project here in HCMC

World’s most endangered turtle found in Hanoi's Dong Mo lake
World’s most endangered turtle found in Hanoi's Dong Mo lake
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

The Vietnamese scientists are doing their utmost to save the endangered turtle species.

Vietnam video-on-demand industry estimated at $105 million in 2020
Vietnam video-on-demand industry estimated at $105 million in 2020
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

Two thirds of marketers in Vietnam expected an increase in the allocation of the digital ad budget to programmatic ad next year, the 2nd highest percentage in the region.

Vietnam destined to take the lead in commercial 5G technology
Vietnam destined to take the lead in commercial 5G technology
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/12/2020 

The number of 5G subscribers nationwide is expected to reach a figure of 6.3 million by 2025, with the deployment of 5G services anticipated to help Vietnamese mobile service providers increase their annual revenue by US$300 million, 

PM approves list of priority technologies for research and development
PM approves list of priority technologies for research and development
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/12/2020 

Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has approved a list of priority technologies for research and development in a bid to facilitate participation in the Fourth Industrial Revolution.

Facebook is blamed for going against Vietnam law
Facebook is blamed for going against Vietnam law
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/12/2020 

Facebook is accused of ignoring Vietnam’s law in removing and blocking violated entries on social network.

HCM City drafts 10-year climate change response plan
HCM City drafts 10-year climate change response plan
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/12/2020 

HCM City has drafted a long-term plan to combat the detrimental effects of climate change.

5G service package fees to be the same as 4G
5G service package fees to be the same as 4G
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

The fifth-generation mobile network is under commercial trial in Hanoi and HCM City. Vietnam is among the few countries in the world that have put 5G into trial use.

Thanh Hoa farmer protects wild birds with his love
Thanh Hoa farmer protects wild birds with his love
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/12/2020 

Mai Van Quan has invested his own money to renovate part of a 22-hectare hill in Ha Trung Town, the central province of Thanh Hoa, to become a shelter for tens of thousands of storks.

Young man starts initiative to reduce plastic waste
Young man starts initiative to reduce plastic waste
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/12/2020 

Pham Thanh Tri from Quang Ngai founded EcoFish Vietnam to teach young people to classify and reuse plastic waste.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN