Fragmented cyber risk alerts are hampering Vietnam's ability to detect and prevent increasingly sophisticated online scams, a senior cybersecurity official warned, calling for coordinated threat intelligence sharing across platforms and industries.
Vietnam needs to move beyond isolated warning systems and establish a coordinated approach to combating online fraud, according to Colonel Dr. Nguyen Hong Quan, Deputy Director of the Cybersecurity Department under the Ministry of Public Security.
He made the remarks at a seminar on building an online risk warning network in Vietnam, held in Hanoi on November 13.
The event was organized by the National Cybersecurity Association and Google under the auspices of the Cybersecurity Department.
Online scams increasingly operate across multiple platforms
Colonel Dr. Nguyen Hong Quan, Deputy Director of the Cybersecurity Department under the Ministry of Public Security, delivers the opening remarks at the seminar on November 13. Photo: Organizers.
Highlighting both the opportunities and challenges created by digital technologies, online platforms and financial services, Quan warned that online fraud is becoming increasingly sophisticated, organized and interconnected across different services.
However, risk warning signals remain scattered among numerous organizations and businesses.
Each organization may detect certain suspicious activities, but the lack of connectivity between their systems limits the ability to identify broader threats and prevent fraudulent activities in time.
"We cannot combat fraud in a highly interconnected cyberspace using fragmented and isolated warning mechanisms," Quan emphasized.
He called for a fundamental shift in cybersecurity strategies, moving from detecting and handling individual incidents to proactively identifying and preventing risks.
Rather than protecting each system independently, organizations should strengthen coordination and share risk indicators across industries, platforms and businesses.
"A data breach not only causes direct losses to organizations and individuals but can also provide criminals with information for further impersonation, fraud and violations of citizens' rights," Quan said. "Therefore, promoting the sharing of risk signals must go hand in hand with ensuring data security, information confidentiality and personal data protection."
He stressed that cooperation between organizations and businesses must be based on clearly defined purposes, responsibilities and information protection mechanisms.
Information sharing should be controlled, legally compliant and designed to avoid creating new risks to users' data, rights and legitimate interests.
The challenges of data sharing and interoperability were also addressed by Colonel Nguyen Huy Luc, a division head at the Cybersecurity Department.
Luc noted that digital data is not only essential to the operation of information systems but also a major target for cybercriminals.
Consequently, ensuring security throughout data sharing and integration processes must remain a priority.
International threat intelligence network offers lessons
Providing an international perspective, Emily Taylor and Lucien Taylor from the Global Signal Exchange (GSE) shared experiences in connecting and exchanging risk indicators across different platforms and services.
Emily Taylor and Lucien Taylor from the Global Signal Exchange share international experiences in coordinating and exchanging online risk warnings. Photo: Organizers.
GSE is a nonprofit threat intelligence sharing platform co-founded by Oxford Information Labs, the Global Anti-Scam Alliance (GASA) and Google to combat online scams in real time.
Since becoming operational in January 2025, GSE has expanded from 40 million to 1.7 billion threat signals.
The network now connects 130 organizations, including Microsoft, Meta, TikTok and law enforcement agencies, through a single set of agreements and technical integrations.
From a technical perspective, GSE uses a ranking system to assess internet infrastructure providers, creating reputational pressure for them to strengthen Know Your Customer (KYC) verification procedures.
The platform also employs a two-way feedback mechanism to monitor whether malicious domains have been effectively taken down.
The two speakers highlighted cooperation between Microsoft and Google as an example of the benefits of coordinated threat intelligence sharing.
In one case, Microsoft disrupted a multimillion-dollar cybercrime marketplace operating on its infrastructure.
The criminal group subsequently moved its operations to Google's infrastructure.
However, through risk signals shared via GSE, the two technology companies coordinated their responses and reduced the group's operational footprint by more than 90%, according to the speakers.
The example demonstrated how shared intelligence can prevent cybercriminals from simply moving between platforms after enforcement actions.
Three priorities for an effective online risk warning network
The seminar brought together representatives from financial businesses, government regulators, law enforcement agencies, retail companies and domestic and international organizations.
Despite their different sectors and responsibilities, Quan said the participants shared a common objective: addressing widespread challenges such as fraud, financial theft and cyberattacks.
He identified three fundamental issues that Vietnam must address to establish an effective online risk warning network capable of connecting information, detecting threats early and proactively preventing scams.
First, establish a practical mechanism for sharing risk signals.
The network must ensure that suspicious information can be detected, verified and converted into timely warnings, with the ultimate goal of preventing fraud before it causes harm.
Second, build a trusted foundation for data security and accountability.
Participating organizations must clearly define their responsibilities and ensure that information is shared for legitimate purposes, within appropriate limits and in compliance with Vietnamese law.
Data security, confidentiality and personal information protection must be integral to the system's design and operation.
Third, encourage active participation from businesses.
The private sector must take greater responsibility for identifying and reporting risks, helping establish an intersectoral coordination mechanism that can be sustained, expanded and translated into meaningful protection for citizens.
Stronger legal frameworks and international cooperation needed
Sharing the same perspective, Colonel Nguyen Huy Luc outlined four major areas of action to strengthen Vietnam's response to cybercrime.
Colonel Nguyen Huy Luc, a division head at the Cybersecurity Department under the Ministry of Public Security, delivers a presentation at the seminar. Photo: Organizers.
The first involves improving the forecasting and assessment of criminal trends to support the development of legislation on cybersecurity, personal data protection and cybercrime prevention.
The second focuses on strengthening coordination among ministries, agencies and law enforcement bodies to prevent, detect and thoroughly investigate cybercrime.
This includes establishing formal mechanisms for exchanging information between relevant organizations.
The third priority is raising public awareness of personal data protection and helping internet users recognize emerging cybercriminal tactics.
The fourth involves expanding international cooperation in training, knowledge sharing and the exchange of technical expertise.
Luc also called for more frequent inspections and assessments of national information and data infrastructure to identify security vulnerabilities promptly.
Organizations should develop contingency plans and strengthen data backup and recovery capabilities to improve resilience against cyber incidents.
According to Quan, the National Cybersecurity Association hopes to promote practical cooperation initiatives that strengthen Vietnam's defensive capabilities and contribute to a safer, more trustworthy digital environment.
"The ultimate goal is not to share more data, but to make effective use of the necessary data to issue earlier warnings, prevent threats more effectively and better protect citizens," Quan concluded.