Apple’s iPhone 17 lineup is finally here, and it brings a major surprise: the debut of the ultra-slim iPhone Air. As the year ends, consumers face a choice between brute force and sleek elegance.
Apple’s unveiling of the iPhone 17 series marks a bold move, especially with the introduction of the iPhone Air – the brand’s thinnest and lightest model yet.
After Samsung released its Galaxy S25 Edge, it’s clear Apple wasn’t willing to sit out the competition in the increasingly heated “ultra-slim smartphone” race.
But the big question is: do consumers truly crave an impossibly thin and lightweight device, or will they stay loyal to the traditional powerhouse – the iPhone 17 Pro Max?
Here’s a detailed comparison of the two contrasting flagships: one is fashionable, lightweight, and almost feather-like; the other is robust, feature-rich, and power-driven.
Design and dimensions
Apple’s ultra-thin iPhone Air just launched. Photo: Apple
Apple has taken a bold design leap this year. The iPhone Air is ultra-thin at just 5.6mm and weighs only 146 grams – practically unheard of in today’s smartphone landscape.
It features a solid titanium frame with Ceramic Shield 2 glass on both sides, enhancing durability despite its slender frame. A slim horizontal camera bar on the back evokes the aesthetic of Google’s Pixel line.
On the other hand, the iPhone 17 Pro Max sticks to a familiar approach. It’s thicker at 8.8mm and heavier, but accommodates a larger battery and a powerful triple-camera system.
The Pro Max features a solid aluminum frame paired with Ceramic Shield 2 glass. Its extended camera bar with three prominent lenses gives it a unique look, though its design may polarize opinions.
Color-wise, the iPhone 17 Pro Max brings a surprise with a bold orange version, reminiscent of the iPhone XR. Meanwhile, the iPhone Air forgoes the classic black variant, a curious omission from Apple.
Display
The orange iPhone 17 Pro Max. Photo: Apple
In a welcome update, the entire iPhone 17 lineup now features 120Hz ProMotion OLED displays, including the iPhone Air – a feature previously reserved for Pro models. The Air sports a 6.5-inch screen with a peak brightness of 3,000 nits, ensuring excellent visibility even in bright sunlight.
The iPhone 17 Pro Max retains its 6.9-inch display size from the previous generation, also boasting 3,000 nits brightness thanks to the Samsung M14 panel. Both models use LDTEE (Low-dielectric TEE) technology, enhancing durability and energy efficiency.
While professional display tests are still forthcoming, users can rest assured that both models offer high-end visuals with minimal differences in quality.
Performance and software
Both iPhone 17 Pro Max and iPhone Air are powered by the A19 Pro chip. Photo: PhoneArena
While their designs differ greatly, both the iPhone 17 Pro Max and iPhone Air are powered by the A19 Pro chip – Apple’s most powerful processor to date, delivering a 40% performance boost over the previous generation. Both models come with 12GB of RAM and start at 256GB of internal storage.
The only storage difference lies with the Pro Max, which offers a 2TB variant for professional photographers, videographers, and heavy users.
Both models run iOS 26 out of the box, featuring significant upgrades in AI, security, and personalization.
Camera
A section of the iPhone 17 Pro Max’s chassis. Photo: Apple
Here lies the most noticeable difference. The iPhone Air includes a single rear camera. Apple claims its advanced image processing can simulate four focal lengths, but in practice, it falls short of the 17 Pro Max.
The iPhone 17 Pro Max features a triple-lens setup, each with a 48MP sensor – a first for Apple. This promises exceptional photography across ultra-wide, wide, and telephoto perspectives. Real-world testing will determine the actual leap in quality.
For users prioritizing photography and video, the Pro Max is clearly the superior choice.
Battery and charging
Battery life remains a challenge for ultra-thin phones. With a thickness of just 5.6mm, the iPhone Air cannot house a large battery. While Apple has not disclosed the battery capacity, it promises “larger battery and improved endurance.” Impressively, the Air still supports MagSafe wireless charging despite its slim profile.
Meanwhile, the Pro Max leverages its bulk to include the largest battery ever in an iPhone, offering extended usage time.
However, Apple has yet to significantly upgrade charging speeds, leaving users somewhat disappointed.
Pricing and positioning
These two iPhones represent two distinct design philosophies:
The iPhone Air targets style-conscious users who value portability and comfort without sacrificing performance. Its starting price is $999 for the 256GB model – reasonable for what Apple calls a “Pro-grade device in a slim shell with a single camera.”
The iPhone 17 Pro Max is designed for users seeking maximum power, longer battery life, superior cameras, and a larger display. It starts at $1,199 – $200 more, but with plenty of added value.
Together, the iPhone Air and iPhone 17 Pro Max form a dual-pronged strategy for Apple. One offers futuristic minimalism and elegance; the other is a full-featured powerhouse for those who want everything in one device.
Whether you choose the Air or the Pro Max, Apple has clearly ushered in a new era of smartphone innovation: one where impossibly thin phones are still incredibly capable, and another where phones evolve into true professional tools.
With clear differences in target audiences, this duo is poised to heat up the smartphone market in late 2025 as consumers weigh their preferences: style or strength?