Tax collections up, but tax revenues from enterprises down

The total collection for the state budget may exceed VND46 trillion may not be good news, because the sources of revenue are uncertain and the collection from enterprises has decreased.

If the total collection exceeds VND46 trillion this year as predicted, this will be the fourth consecutive year the budget revenue has exceeded the estimate. However, many problems exist.

Tax collections up, but tax revenues from enterprises down



It is estimated that the revenue from domestic sources will exceed 1.9 percent only compared with the estimate. Meanwhile, the three sources of revenue from state-owned enterprises (SOEs), foreign invested enterprises (FIEs) and private enterprises are lower than estimated.

The three economic sectors have seen decreases of 5.9 percent, 4.1 percent and 1.9 percent than planned. The National Assembly’s Finance and Budget Committee estimates that the loss of revenue is roughly VND23 trillion.

This is the third consecutive year Vietnam saw revenue from the sources lower than the estimate, even though the National Assembly earlier this year set a lower target.

This is the third consecutive year Vietnam saw revenue from the sources lower than the estimate, even though the National Assembly earlier this year set a lower target.

Economists pointed out that the Law on Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) Support took effect on January 1, 2018, but according to the government’s report, the collection from private enterprises is low, estimated at VND4.5 trillion in 2019, or 1.9 percent lower than estimate.

 


One of the major reasons behind this is that SMEs are meeting difficulties in production and business.

Meanwhile, the increase in revenue comes from unstable sources of revenue, including collection from granting rights for mining and water natural resources (up by 40.8 percent), from land use (+ 29.9 percent) and from lotteries (6.2 percent).

“Why does revenue from enterprises continue to decrease, while the figures about economic growth are so ‘beautiful’?” said Dinh Son Hung, former deputy head of the HCM City Institute for Development Studies (HIDS).

The economist went on to say that SOEs receive a lot of preferences from the State, especially in exploiting natural resources and minerals, but the revenue from them remains low.

As for the foreign invested economic sector, Hung said this is the most profitable sector thanks to excellent business administration, so he doesn’t believe the revenue from the sector is decreasing.

“It is necessary to find out what is behind the decrease in FIEs’ contribution to the state budget collection, and if this is because of unreasonable tax policies and problems in the source of revenue,” Hung said.

Though revenue from SOEs, FIEs and private enterprises has been decreasing for the last three years, the government has still set a high target of revenue from them for 2020, with increases of 6.3 percent, 11.6 percent and 14.3 percent, respectively, compared with 2019.

Chi Mai

Vietnam’s GDP too heavily dependent on foreign-invested enterprises: economists

Vietnam’s GDP too heavily dependent on foreign-invested enterprises: economists

Commenting about the reliance of Vietnam’s economy on FIEs (foreign invested enterprises), one economist noted that “when FIEs sneeze, the Vietnamese economy catches a cold".

FIEs favored while Vietnamese enterprises at a disadvantage

FIEs favored while Vietnamese enterprises at a disadvantage

The problems caused by FIEs, such as transfer pricing and investment under others’ names, have been noted in the Party Politburo’s Resolution 50 for the first time.

 
 

Other News

.
Retail industry strives to exploit US$200-billion market
Retail industry strives to exploit US$200-billion market
BUSINESSicon  03/04/2021 

The Vietnamese market had a spectacular leap in scale last year, becoming one of the 16 most successful emerging economies in the world. In which, the retail sector was extremely attractive and full of potentials, with lots of room for development.

Markets blacklisted for selling counterfeit goods
Markets blacklisted for selling counterfeit goods
BUSINESSicon  03/04/2021 

The US Trade Representative (USTR) office has blacklisted Vietnam's well-known markets in its 2020 review, for reasons of counterfeiting goods. Dong Xuan Market in Hanoi and Ben Thanh Market in HCMC have been named on the USTR blacklist. 

Car dealers begin clearance sales, reduce prices by up to VND100 million
Car dealers begin clearance sales, reduce prices by up to VND100 million
BUSINESSicon  03/04/2021 

Car sale agents have launched promotion programs in an effort to clear stock, but the price reductions are lower than those in the same period last year.

Mekong Delta: spoiled pigs eating sweets, and other unusual phenomena
Mekong Delta: spoiled pigs eating sweets, and other unusual phenomena
BUSINESSicon  03/04/2021 

Nguyen Hong Trang’s family in Vinh My A commune in Bac Lieu province raises pigs. More than a year ago, her sow gave birth to 11 baby pigs, one of which weighed only two kilos. As it could not suckle much, it stayed small.

Bank shares in demand as banks report huge profits
Bank shares in demand as banks report huge profits
BUSINESSicon  03/04/2021 

The capitalization value of some banks has increased by one billion dollars within a short time.

Local authorities struggle to stop real estate bubble
Local authorities struggle to stop real estate bubble
FEATUREicon  03/04/2021 

The real estate market remains feverish not because of high demand and short supply, but because of speculation, experts have said.

Demand for industrial land rising: Savills Vietnam
Demand for industrial land rising: Savills Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  02/04/2021 

The sudden increase in demand for land, factories, and warehouses in Vietnam has pushed up rental costs at industrial parks (IPs) near major cities, according to Savills Vietnam.

Finance ministry studies legal framework for cryptocurrencies
Finance ministry studies legal framework for cryptocurrencies
BUSINESSicon  02/04/2021 

The Ministry of Finance is studying the legal framework for managing cryptocurrencies on stock exchanges which would pave the way for legal cryptocurrency transactions in Vietnam.

Vietnam’s airlines preparing to fly non-stop to US, resume international flights
Vietnam’s airlines preparing to fly non-stop to US, resume international flights
BUSINESSicon  02/04/2021 

Despite the Covid-19 crisis, Bamboo Airways and Vietnam Airlines have announced plans to fly non-stop to the US by the end of this year.

Plenty of room remains for growth of consumer credit market: Insiders
Plenty of room remains for growth of consumer credit market: Insiders
BUSINESSicon  01/04/2021 

Though Vietnam’s outstanding consumer credit almost tripled over the last decade, its share of total outstanding loans is yet to keep pace with that of its regional nations. 

Owner of US$7 billion system, billionaire Nguyen Dang Quang takes new step
Owner of US$7 billion system, billionaire Nguyen Dang Quang takes new step
BUSINESSicon  01/04/2021 

After Masan Group's acquisition of Vingroup’s retail chain, Masan’s Nguyen Dang Quang took great steps to master the $7 billion system and form an ecosystem for Vietnamese people.

Banks required to issue chip cards for security
Banks required to issue chip cards for security
BUSINESSicon  01/04/2021 

Vietnamese commercial banks are required to issue chip ATM cards to improve customers’ transaction security from March 31, according to the State Bank of Vietnam’s Circular No. 22/2020/TT-NHNN.

Industries bet on vaccine visa measures
Industries bet on vaccine visa measures
BUSINESSicon  01/04/2021 

In line with the global vaccine visa drive, Vietnam’s latest move to complete technical infrastructure for the availability of such a travel document in April is expected to revive industries, heralding strong economic recovery ahead.

Big businesses pour billions of dong into land purchases in Da Nang
Big businesses pour billions of dong into land purchases in Da Nang
FEATUREicon  01/04/2021 

While other land markets are hot, Da Nang remains very quiet, prompting many investors from Hanoi and HCM City to collect land plots in advantageous positions in "bottom fishing" deals.

More than 10 sugar mills shut down because of big losses
More than 10 sugar mills shut down because of big losses
FEATUREicon  01/04/2021 

Many sugar mills have had to shut down because they cannot compete with imports.

Vietnam Airlines unveils coveted US flight proposals
Vietnam Airlines unveils coveted US flight proposals
BUSINESSicon  31/03/2021 

Vietnam Airlines’ dream of a direct commercial flight to the US is being quickened as a way to shelter from the financial trouble amid the pandemic, with repatriation flights being the pre-runner for future non-stop journeys across the Pacific Ocean.

Rapid growth of online delivery services
Rapid growth of online delivery services
BUSINESSicon  01/04/2021 

The sudden, unexpected and virulent spread of the Covid-19 pandemic brought about a change in perception and planning in consumer sales behavior, and many well established businesses made a strong shift towards online delivery servicing. 

New strategy to place priority on green growth
New strategy to place priority on green growth
BUSINESSicon  31/03/2021 

The Ministry of Planning and Investment is drafting a national green growth strategy and plans to submit it to the Government by June to accelerate the transition towards a carbon-neutral economy in Vietnam.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 2
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 2
BUSINESSicon  02/04/2021 

New interest rate level forecast in Q2 2021

Many Vietnamese exporters see profit soar during COVID-19
Many Vietnamese exporters see profit soar during COVID-19
BUSINESSicon  31/03/2021 

Many Vietnamese exporters have seen a sudden increase in profits during the COVID-19 pandemic.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN