BOT projects need careful consideration

The Government's website (baochinhphu.vn) recently published an interview with Dr Tran Chung, President of the Association of Private Investors in Road Transport, on strong and weak points of BOT projects in Vietnam.

Banks are worried as BOT projects incur losses
Fee collection suspension lifted at three BOT projects

BOT projects need careful consideration
VETC worker monitor vehicles driving through Can Tho – Phung Hiep BOT tollgate. — VNA/VNS Photo (Illustrative image)

As an expert on public transport projects in Vietnam, what do you think of the public-private partnership draft law?

In recent years, the public-private partnership (PPP) model has been applied rather widely in the transport field, particularly in build-operate-transfer (BOT) projects. In this model, private investors use their own money to build and operate the project after its completion for a certain period of time. Then the project is transferred to the Government.

The BOT model has opened up an opportunity for the private sector to mobilise capital resources from different economic sectors to invest in road construction projects and operate them for some time before transferring them to the Government.

Meanwhile, PPPs have opened opportunities and conditions to mobilise capital resources from the private sector in the development of the country’s infrastructure and socio-economic development as a whole.

However, in reality, according to reports from the State Inspectors and the State Audit, there remains many obstacles in the Government’s policies and institution.

Some of the most prominent issues are selection of the investors, project announcement, rules on the management of investment capital, the same management format is applied to both PPP and public projects, and many others.

In project implementation, quite a few problems have arisen, particularly financial issues like credit, service charges and others. These problems need to be settled as soon as possible.

What are the differences in investment between the BOT and PPP projects?

Resolution No.473 of the National Assembly Standing Committee states clearly that BOT projects are only applied to new roads and it is up to road users to decide whether they want to use them or not. In other the words, BOT is a type of contract with a special financial mechanism allowing road users to decide whether they want to use it or not. If they want to use it, they have to pay the fee.

However, at present, many national/provincial roads need to be repaired or upgraded while the State budget is limited.

 

That’s why I support the Government’s decision to include in the Law on Public Private Partnership which covers different formats, like that of the PPP, build-transfer and lease and build-service and lease. Of course, in these contract forms, the Government will settle financial issues for investors in several ways (the financial settlement may be prolonged for many years) and road users don’t have to pay fees.

Recently, some BOT investors have complained that risk sharing has not been included in the contracts. Don’t you think a risk sharing mechanism should be written in the contracts to protect all signatories?

In a market economy, a legal value is the primary issue that any contract has to abide by.

So, in my opinion, before signing the contract, both Vietnamese agencies and the investors have not foreseen risks that may occur nor found solutions to solve them. In reality, no lawsuit on such an issue has been reported. So the upcoming Law on Public Private Partnership should think of the establishment of the Viet Nam International Arbitration Centre (VIAC). And VIAC will be the place for settle mishaps in BOT projects or PPP projects.

Do you have any suggestions for the development of the Law on Public-Private-Partnership?

The PPP law should be promulgated as soon as possible.

It should cover various areas, including capital investment management, financial settlement and others.

The law should also differentiate the concepts between projects using the State budget with the PPP project.

What is the role of localities in transport projects that run through their territory?

Local authorities have the responsibility in land settlement for the road to run through their local territory as well as to give their comments or suggestions to ensure the rights of all Vietnamese people using the road.

In addition, the local government should be involved in the supervision process in the project throughout its life cycle.

VNS

 
 

Other News

.
Two new expressways to be built in Mekong Delta
Two new expressways to be built in Mekong Delta
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

The Ministry of Transport has directed the Cuu Long Corporation for Investment Development and Project Management of Infrastructure (CIPM) to conduct a pre-feasibility study for two expressway projects in the Mekong Delta.

Work on HCM City’s Metro Line No.2 to begin next year
Work on HCM City’s Metro Line No.2 to begin next year
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

Work on Ho Chi Minh City’s Metro Line No.2, connecting Ben Thanh Market and Tham Luong, will start in 2021, according to the city’s Management Authority for Urban Railways (MAUR).

Japan finances HCM City’s upgrade of sewer system
Japan finances HCM City’s upgrade of sewer system
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

The Japanese Government will provide a non-refundable aid worth 1.88 billion JPY (16.84 million USD) for Ho Chi Minh City to upgrade its existing sewerage system using trenchless technologies.

Hustle and bustle returns to Hanoi after impact of COVID-19
Hustle and bustle returns to Hanoi after impact of COVID-19
PHOTOSicon  23/02/2020 

Outdoor entertainment areas, commercial centres, and relic sites throughout Hanoi have been gradually becoming busier over the past few days following a slow month after being affected by COVID-19.

Lam Dong pilots building Vietnam’s first green urban village
Lam Dong pilots building Vietnam’s first green urban village
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

The authorities of Lam Dong has asked relevant agencies to supplement and complete a plan on the construction of a green urban village – the first of its kind in Vietnam – in Xuan Tho commune, Da Lat city.

Vietnam reports no new COVID-19 cases since Feb 13
Vietnam reports no new COVID-19 cases since Feb 13
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

Vietnam has reported no new confirmed cases of the new coronavirus (COVID-19) since February 13, heard at a meeting of the National Steering Committee for COVID-19 Prevention and Control in Hanoi yesterday.

Japan helps HCM City Pasteur Institute respond to COVID-19
Japan helps HCM City Pasteur Institute respond to COVID-19
SOCIETYicon  23/02/2020 

The Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) on February 21 presented the first package of biologicals worth 1 million JPY (over 8,900 USD) to the Pasteur Institute in HCMC in support of its response to COVID-19.

Language, law course opened for Vietnamese living in Cambodia
Language, law course opened for Vietnamese living in Cambodia
VIETNAM & WORLDicon  22/02/2020 

A training course to teach Khmer language and provide knowledge of culture, history and law of Cambodia for people of Vietnamese origin in Cambodia who wish to get Cambodian citizenship was opened in Takeo province of Cambodia on February 22.

Coronavirus: Pregnant nurse 'propaganda' sparks backlash
Coronavirus: Pregnant nurse 'propaganda' sparks backlash
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

The nine-month-pregnant nurse was portrayed as heroic for continuing to work on the frontlines.

Coronavirus: South Korea steps up measures as infections spike
Coronavirus: South Korea steps up measures as infections spike
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

South Korea has stepped up measures to contain the spread of the deadly new coronavirus, as confirmed infections rose sharply for a second day.

Hanoi student wins scholarships to five US high schools
Hanoi student wins scholarships to five US high schools
SOCIETYicon  22/02/2020 

A Vietnamese student has just won scholarships to five high schools in the US.

Nearly 40,000 train tickets returned due to Covid-19
Nearly 40,000 train tickets returned due to Covid-19
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

Vietnam Railways (VR) said that its revenue dropped by nearly VND65 billion (US$2.8 million) in the past 19 days compared to the same period last year due to the novel coronavirus outbreak.

Vietnamese medical staff win fight with COVID-19
Vietnamese medical staff win fight with COVID-19
SOCIETYicon  22/02/2020 

Amid global concerns over coronavirus, the full recovery of the first two patients who tested positive for the virus in Vietnam affirmed the professional competence of Vietnamese physicians and the Government’s efforts to address the epidemic.

Hanoi’s biggest market quiet amid coronavirus fears
Hanoi’s biggest market quiet amid coronavirus fears
PHOTOSicon  22/02/2020 

Hanoi’s biggest market at Dong Xuan is deserted amid fears of coronavirus.

HCM City proposes school closure extension for coronavirus prevention
HCM City proposes school closure extension for coronavirus prevention
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

HCM City authorities have proposed further temporary school closures until the end of March for fear of coronavirus.

Hanoians queue to receive free hand wash
Hanoians queue to receive free hand wash
PHOTOSicon  21/02/2020 

Many people in Hang Dao Ward, Hanoi have been provided with free hand wash during the coronavirus outbreak. 

No new suspected coronavirus cases in HCM City
No new suspected coronavirus cases in HCM City
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

All three patients who tested positive for COVID-19 and were treated in HCM City hospitals have recovered fully and all 32 suspected cases in the city have tested negative as of Wednesday.

Three coronavirus patients leave hospital, 15 out of 16 cured
Three coronavirus patients leave hospital, 15 out of 16 cured
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

Three patients from the northern province of Vinh Phuc were declared free from the coronavirus and discharged from hospital on Thursday.

HCM City needs about 80,000 labourers in Q1
HCM City needs about 80,000 labourers in Q1
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

Around 80,000 workers are needed in Ho Chi Minh City for the first quarter of this year, according to the HCM City Human Resources Forecast and Labour Market Information (FALMI) Centre.

Two more COVID-9 patients discharged from hospital in Vinh Phuc
Two more COVID-9 patients discharged from hospital in Vinh Phuc
SOCIETYicon  21/02/2020 

Two COVID-19 patients in the northern province of Vinh Phuc were released from a local general clinic on February 20 afternoon.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN