thu hut nhan tai No4 (1).jpg
The Vietnam talent strategy must empower scientists with genuine autonomy and judge success by practical solutions rather than bureaucratic metrics. 

Experts say spending 0.1 percent of annual GDP on talent will fail unless Vietnam moves beyond vanity credentials. The Vietnam talent strategy must empower scientists with genuine autonomy and judge success by practical solutions rather than bureaucratic metrics. Dr. Tran Hai Linh, President of the Vietnam-Korea Business and Investment Association, said the crucial point lies not merely in budget scale, but in shifting perspective: talent is a strategic resource to elevate productivity, master technology, and boost national competitiveness.

If designed and executed effectively, this investment could trigger a spillover effect extending far beyond a single recruitment program or research institution.

However, he asserted that allocating funds is a necessary condition, but not a sufficient one. A large sum of money does not automatically produce outstanding scientists, valuable inventions, or strong tech enterprises. The question to ask from the outset is: “Which development problems are we investing in, who are we selecting to execute them, what conditions are we providing, and how do we evaluate results?”

Linh said investing in talent is not spending money to amass more polished resumes, but to gain the capability to solve tough problems. The value of 0.1 percent of GDP, if implemented, must be measured by generated knowledge, technology, productivity, and social benefit, not merely by the scale of expenditure.

No excessive emphasis on academic titles, degrees

For years, discussions of talent policies have focused heavily on how much financial support should be offered under the so-called “red carpet” approach, what housing incentives should be provided, and how many professors, PhD holders and experts can be recruited.

But the more important questions are what they are assigned to do, whether they are trusted, whether they have sufficient authority and resources, and whether their results are assessed fairly. 

Linh agreed with the approach which says that “rolling out the red carpet” is necessary, but only the first step. Talented people may choose a country, research institute or business because of its remuneration policies. But they can stay, contribute and achieve results only when they are trusted, assigned the right tasks, given adequate working conditions and evaluated fairly. 

He therefore argued that the focus must shift from “how many people have we attracted?” to “what have we enabled talented people to accomplish?”

First, making effective use of talent must begin with assigning the right problems. An AI expert should be tasked with developing a solution, product or technology platform with specific objectives. A materials scientist should have the opportunity to build a research team, access equipment and collaborate with manufacturing businesses. 

A public administration expert should be given room to test reform initiatives. If talented people are recruited but assigned routine administrative work unrelated to their expertise, both money and opportunities are wasted.

Second, Linh noted that authority must go hand in hand with responsibility, and that an environment respecting competence and differences must be established. Talented people often take new approaches and sometimes raise questions that challenge existing practices. 

If an organization values seniority, hierarchy or superficial consensus above all else, innovation can easily be stifled. Heads of agencies and units must therefore take responsibility for protecting proposals grounded in scientific evidence, fostering healthy debate and ensuring that personal relationships do not influence professional assessments.

He also called for evaluations based on substantive contributions, rather than placing excessive emphasis on academic titles, degrees or the number of published papers. Academic achievements are important, but the criteria must be appropriate to each position.

“I believe there should be clear career pathways for Vietnamese professionals overseas who want to contribute. Not everyone can immediately relocate to Vietnam permanently. "We could introduce project-based work, concurrent appointments, joint laboratories, co-supervision of doctoral students, long-term technology advisory roles and two-way personnel exchanges,” Linh proposed.

Another factor that cannot be overlooked is the role of leaders. Central policies can establish the framework, but the culture of valuing talent depends heavily on direct managers: whether they dare to assign challenging tasks, delegate authority, listen to criticism and protect those who do the right thing. Without this, he stressed, “the red carpet can easily end right at the office door.”

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Duong Minh Hai said attracting talent is only the first step, while making effective use of it is the decisive measure. An outstanding professor or engineer might receive generous remuneration, but would struggle to deliver commensurate results without the authority to recruit colleagues, timely access to equipment or relief from spending most of their time on administrative procedures.

Tran Thuong